Tuesday 22 December 2015

West Highland College Christmas Card


Nollaig Chridheil/Happy Christmas



Tonight is our last class of the term and I am feeling rather pleased on two counts:-

1) that my Ruraltopia assignment is now ready for submission, and

2) that my "Snowdrops in Snow" photograph (Kilmore churchyard, Sleat) has been chosen by the Principal of West Highland College to feature on their 2015 Christmas Card. (see below)

Because they are using one of my images West Highland College are donating £25 to the charity of my choice which is  Childrens Hospice Association Scotland (CHAS).   Thank you for this privilege.


Nollaig Chridheil dhuibh uile - 

Happy Christmas to you all!







Sunday 20 December 2015

Evaluation - Ruraltopia (4)


"If your photographs aren't good enough, you're not close enough" ....    Robert Capa


EVALUATION 

My aim was to visually interpret 'Ruraltopia' through a range of photographs (see previous posts for Ruraltopia - (1), (2) and (3).  

My chosen subjects were:
  • crofters working in their own crofting environment portrayed in the documentary genre
  • indigenous people - crofters portrayed in the portraiture genre


The following are my six final selected images, with self-evaluations, including strengths and areas for improvement:-
(click on online images to view larger - hard copies of these images are available in assignment folder)

Documentary images are all in monochrome emulating the style of Gus Wylie (Ref. Ruraltopia 1)







1. Crofter in Kitchen
24 mm
1/3
f/18
ISO 100
Comments
Captured the moment in a natural setting as crofter was actively engaged in paperwork when I arrived while natural props were available on the kitchen table (cattle medication as well as lunch remnants). True Wylie style.  Cropped the image in PS Elements to remove bright light reflections on wall coming through kitchen window.
Strengths
Used wide end of 24-120 mm lens to capture sharp detail and get a large depth of field. Nice tones from light and shadows in the kitchen.
Area (s) for Improvement
Consider asking subject to move his position at the table (limited space for tripod in kitchen) in order to cope with challenge of bright light from window.  Faster shutter speed would have coped with dog movement (removed in close crop – see contact sheet)


2. Crofter at Sheep Fank
24 mm
1/80
f/13
ISO 6400
Comments
Good detail in shot, especially of the sheep’s eye and showing man interacting with animal  (as in Gus Wylie images)
Strengths
Successfully coped with very poor light conditions (late winter afternoon) and used high ISO on full frame camera as well as fill in flash to capture image.  Got in close with camera for detailed action capture.
Area (s) for Improvement
Consider relationship of flash and ISO to address poor lighting
Explore use of faster shutter speeds in documentary photography


3. Crofter and Creel
24 mm
1/10
f/14
ISO 6400
Comments
Interior of croft house because of very inclement weather so man mending creel indoors; image editing done in PSE to sharpen image.
Strengths
Successfully used a high ISO to capture the shot as well as using the natural light available from the window.
Area (s) for Improvement
A faster shutter speed shutter would have again resulted in a sharper image especially to cope with the slight hand movement of the crofter when working on the mending his fishing creel.

 Portraiture images have all been converted to monochrome in post production to reflect the style of Yousuf Karsh. (Ref. Ruraltopia 1)






1. Crofter with pipe
110 mm
1/80
f/4.5
ISO 6400
Comments
A very relaxed subject so photo shoot was an engaging experience.  Used PSE to clone some of background as subject’s chair was only partly covered by a jacket.  The resulting photograph has pleasing detail.
Strengths
Nice sharp detailed portrait which catches the essence of the character.  Used high ISO to complement natural light from window. Shallow DOF and subject stands out from background.
Area (s) for Improvement
Consider setting up the scene beforehand, eg perhaps have a completely dark background or use cover to give the desired effect.
Consider use of lighting in portraiture (which we are about to study in class).


2. Crofter with cap at Knock Farm
112mm
1/1600
f/4.8
ISO 6400
Comments
Subject is a very shy individual so challenge in getting to focus on his eyes.  Used post processing in Photoshop Elements to try out a low key image and also added extra dof to image but discarded both manipulations as the original image is more effective. (see contact sheet).
Strengths
 Working outdoors allows natural light to give a pleasing background and shallow dof.  Creative shot in that emotion is captured (his shy, slow smile) which defines his personality.
Area (s) for Improvement
 Think about composition and framing - try to position subject's eyes using the rule of thirds to give a more balanced composition.


3. Crofter at Sheep Fank
102 mm
1/800
f/4.5
ISO 6400
Comments
This portrait shot was a quick opportunity at the Sheep Fank before the sheep dosing documentary shots were captured and the subject had just returned from gathering sheep on the moor.  The high ISO gives some grain to the portrait which is very effective.
Strengths
The telephoto lens is good for blurring background and drawing subject into focus.  Natural outdoor light and use of wide aperture make a good image.  
Area (s) for Improvement
Consider if retaking the shot to include more of the hand resting on the sheep fank gate.  Learn how to use a reflector outdoors for portraiture. This would bounce the light back on to the subject's face.  I enjoyed the portraiture experience but I am very much an amateur so I still have a lot to learn about taking portraits. 




SUMMARY


This assignment was very much a learning process, in that being self-critical makes me want to go and reshoot these images using the knowledge and understanding I have gained from my first experience, both with documentary photography and with formal portraiture.  My technical challenges encountered were generally problems with lighting - wet November weather in the Isle of Skye is not usually conducive to photography and exposure must be mastered to overcome the obstacles encountered.  I would now approach the technical decisions re shutter speed differently and would also be more mindful in considering the shot beforehand - in other words, I would not rush into taking the photograph and  maximise the allocated time slot by being more in control.  

In my personal development plan in my Photography Journal, I cite becoming familiar with the D600 FX camera settings as an objective - the practical work in this assignment has made me consider camera controls and exposure in greater depth.

Post production manipulation has meant that I have experimented with image editing and tried out some techniques in Photoshop Elements which has helped to progress my skills.

Did I meet my aims and reflect the theme of "Ruraltopia"?  I will say yes because my images, though not technically nor compositionally perfect, portray crofting and crofters in Skye - a true snapshot as it is now in 2015.  This is what both Gus Wylie on his Hebridean quest portrayed and of course Yousuf Karsh's portraiture is iconic.  It is rewarding to reflect and recognise that I was making the pictures, and not just taking them.

Mostly I discovered something about myself; while working completely out of my photographic comfort zone (my preference would be to photograph landscape which was not an option for this assignment)  I found that there is something extremely appealing about photographing people.  Perhaps it was the social interaction between the photographer and the subject, the capturing of the character; the capture of the emotion and of the personality, documenting that moment in time that made it very satisfying.    Indeed, I find the prospect of further exploring the genres of portraiture and documentary very appealing!

"It is more important to click with people than to click the shutter" ....    Alfred Eisenstaedt


Photography Planning - Ruraltopia (3)

"You don't take a photograph, you make it."  Ansel Adams


I have learned that indeed there is a difference between taking and making a photograph, mainly to do with photography practices and having a plan for and structure to the creative process.  As an educationalist, I groan internally and think of forward planning, which the majority of teachers dislike because teachers wish to teach and therefore photographers like to take pictures.  But just as planning class lessons has clearly a positive point, so does planning for photography. 

From my research on Yousuf Karsh, the world's greatest ever portraiture photographer, I find that he clearly highlights his meticulous preparation and research before his photography shooting.

 "It was in London, I started the practice of doing my homework ......."  Yousuf Karsh
(Ref.    http://www.karsh.org/#/the_man/biography)


So in order to make photographs for 'Ruraltopia'  I need to have a plan. I hope to utilise some of  of the techniques used by my chosen photographers - Gus Wylie (documentary genre) and Yousuf Karsh (portraiture genre) -  following my research on their photography.


AIM:  

  • To visually interpret Ruraltopia through a range of photographs which demonstrate careful planning, creative composition and technical competence;
  • To use the subject matter of crofters working in their local crofting environment and portray them in the documentary genre;
  • To use the subject matter of indigenous people and portray individual crofters in the portraiture genre;
  • To use the model of planning, shooting, evaluating for photographs in order to select final images for assignment.



TECHNIQUES

  • Make contact with individuals beforehand to fix ideal location of shoot, eg their working environment;
  • Tell the story in documentary by shooting what happens naturally, remembering to capture the details - set the scene;
  • Capture the true essence of the person in portraiture, focus on the eyes/hands;
  • Use an effective focal range, wide end of 24mm - 120 mm Nikkor lens (shooting with Nikon D600)  for documentary - smaller aperture to give larger depth of field to include detail;
  • Use 70-300 telephoto lens with Nikon D600 for portraiture to create blurred background and give a comfortable working distance -  wide aperture/small DOF to give shallow focus;
  • Establish social interaction with subject to put them at ease;
  • Use tripod for better quality and to get more creative and sharp images;
  • Use natural light (outdoor environment if possible) - consider the available light and use fill flash and ISO adjustments as required;
  • Prepare to wait and see what happens naturally for a good documentary capture;
  • Produce monochrome images in the style of both Gus Wylie (documentary) and Yousuf Karsh (portraiture); shoot in colour and use processing for monochrome conversion;
  • Use post-production techniques for image files using iPhoto and Photoshop Elements 13 for completion of the task;
  • Produce contact sheets for test images - to be presented in folder along with final six images.

EQUIPMENT








  • Nikon D600 camera body 
  • 24-120mm kit lens (Nikkor)
  • 70-300mm telephoto lens (Nikkor)
  • MeFoto Travel Tripod Kit
  • Props were not pre-planned but subjects were photographed using recognisable props as they were used in the natural working environment



  • SUBJECTS/LOCATIONS

    • Arrange photo shoots with four different crofters, to allow choice in final selection
    • Location 1 - Crofter A -  new farm steadings - Knock Farm, Sleat
    • Location 2 - Crofter B - Crofthouse kitchen and croft land - Tarskavaig, Sleat
    • Location 3 - Crofter C - Ord moorland and Sheep Fank, Sleat
    • Location 4 - Crofter D - Crofthouse interior, Ardvasar, Sleat


    Mt next blog post will feature how I achieved the aims of the plan, the techniques used and the challenges encountered along with my evaluation of the selected photographs.  My assignment submission will include test prints and contact sheets as well as hard copies of final six images.
    The images below are from each of the locations from where the photo shoots took place.  (Click on each image to view large).

    "You don't make a photograph just with a camera.  You bring to the act of photography all the pictures you have seen, the books you have read, the music you have heard, the people you have loved."   Ansel Adams


    Knock Farm Steadings

    Tarskavaig Croft


    Ord Moorland


    Ardvasar crofter at Crofthouse

    Friday 18 December 2015

    Ruraltopia (2)

    "There is a brief moment when all there is in a man's mind and soul and spirit is reflected through his eye, his hands, his attitude.  This is the moment to record".  Yousuf Karsh






    I now continue to interpret Ruraltopia with my second set of subject matter, by capturing the essence and character of individual crofters through the portraiture genre.





    Yousuf Karsh

    Portraiture Photographer Research: Yousuf Karsh (1908-2002)




    My research into Yousuf Karsh's life gives me a rags to riches story which is an inspiration to any would be photographer.  Born in Armenian Turkey (then known as the Ottaman Empire) Karsh experienced a horrific early childhood with relatives massacred and his sister dying of starvation as the family fled from genocide.  They eventually settled in Syria in 1922 and two years later, his father sent the 16-year old Yousuf to Canada to live with a photographer uncle in Quebec.  


    This resulted in a training opportunity with a portrait photographer in Boston, USA, with Karsh returning in 1931 to Canada to work with John Garo, a photographer in Ottawa and subsequently taking over his studio. During his apprenticeship with John Garo,  Karsh was taught to see his subject in terms of light, shadow and form.   He took the opportunity to play with shadows and lighting,  thus producing some very dramatic light in his shots and often used low key images to create a great portrait.



    By the early 70s "Karsh of Ontario" was known as one of the top portrait studios in the world and in 1973 Karsh moved his studio into a local hotel, remaining there for almost twenty years until he retired, having had a career of over 60 years in photography and gaining the reputation of being one of the most accomplished and famous photographers of all time.  



    His portraiture work is iconic and even today, 13 years after his death, can be seen on postage stamps, bank notes as well as in photography books and in galleries.  Canada Post commemorated the 100th anniversary of his birth by releasing three stamps featuring Karsh's work.  The Bank of England announced in April 2013 that Karsh's iconic ~Churchill portrait is to feature on the new £5 note being produced in 2016.


    There is a wealth of research material available online about Karsh not least the extremely informative website  (ref www.karsh.org)  belonging to The Estate of Yousuf Karsh and containing sections on 

    (a)  The Man - a life in images, a brief biography, awards and some hugely appealing interviews with Karsh himself, which are a very useful resource when researching this famous and great individual.  

    (b)  His Work - images, bibliography and exhibitions.  This website really is an excellent resource and is to be highly recommended as an online learning tool.  

    I enjoyed completing the 9-question online survey and giving  feedback which is a clear strength of the website, as it gives an opportunity to interact with the viewers. http://www.karsh.org





    The following images are the two I have chosen as having an influence on my selected portraiture genre:-



    1.  Possibly the most famous ever portrait is the iconic capture of Sir Winston Churchill by Karsh in 1941 which appeared on the cover of Life magazine and was a pivotal moment in Karsh's career.

    Karsh published 15 books of his photographs writing about his portrait sessions, during which he would talk to his subject asking questions to make them feel relaxed while he set up the shot.  The following is his description of that famous portrait opportunity with Churchill as recorded by Karsh

     (Ref.http://www.karsh.org/#/the_work/portraits/winston_churchill)




    "My portrait of Winston Churchill changed my life.   I knew after I had taken it that it was an important picture, but I could hardly have dreamed that it would become one of the most widely reproduced images in the history of photography. In 1941, Churchill visited first Washington and then Ottawa. The Prime Minister, Mackenzie King, invited me to be present. After the electrifying speech, I waited in the Speaker’s Chamber where, the evening before, I had set up my lights and camera. The Prime Minister, arm-in-arm with Churchill and followed by his entourage, started to lead him into the room. I switched on my floodlights; a surprised Churchill growled, “What’s this, what’s this?” No one had the courage to explain. I timorously stepped forward and said, “Sir, I hope I will be fortunate enough to make a portrait worthy of this historic occasion.” He glanced at me and demanded, “Why was I not told?” When his entourage began to laugh, this hardly helped matters for me. Churchill lit a fresh cigar, puffed at it with a mischievous air, and then magnanimously relented. “You may take one.” Churchill’s cigar was ever present. I held out an ashtray, but he would not dispose of it. I went back to my camera and made sure that everything was all right technically. I waited; he continued to chomp vigorously at his cigar. I waited. Then I stepped toward him and, without premeditation, but ever so respectfully, I said, “Forgive me, sir,” and plucked the cigar out of his mouth. By the time I got back to my camera, he looked so belligerent he could have devoured me. It was at that instant that I took the photograph."




    The Roaring Lion -
    Churchill in defiant mood.








    The "less memorable" 
    second photo was 
    favoured by Karsh.

    Karsh has used a lighter coloured background which makes Churchill's dark suit stand out.  The stance Churchill has adopted placing his hand on hip and arm on chair along with the forbidding expression on his face defines his personality.  Karsh managed to portray a powerful and determined leader which was what the world needed to see at that time. The image was named "The Roaring Lion following Churchill's remark that Karsh could even make a roaring lion stand still to be photographed, and he allowed him a second photograph.















    Albert Einstein 1948


    2.  My second selection is Karsh's portrait of Albert Einstein (1948).  Here Karsh focuses on the position of Einstein's hands to portray the simple, kindly, almost childlike quality he attributes to Einstein (see below).  The lighting contrast in the image brings the subject forward, giving a good depth to the photo.

    Karsh states in his description:- (Ref. http://www.karsh.org/#/the_work/portraits/albert_einstein)


    At Princeton’s Institute for Advanced Study, I found Einstein a simple, kindly, almost childlike man, too great for any of the postures of eminence. One did not have to understand his science to feel the power of his mind or the force of his personality. He spoke sadly, yet serenely, as one who had looked into the universe, far past mankind’s small affairs. When I asked him what the world would be like were another atomic bomb to be dropped, he replied wearily, “Alas, we will no longer be able to hear the music of Mozart.”








    While, I realise that my Ruraltopia portraiture photography cannot in any way draw parallels with that of the revered Yousuf Karsh, there is much to learn from my research into his career and techniques.  Karsh wished to know his subject  before he took the portrait so he studied them well beforehand and he learned to keep the conversation going to put them at ease.  With my three crofting portraits below, I did feel a rapport with my subjects as we had a common identity in crofting culture and heritage and this point of contact became an easy conversation topic.  

    Karsh studied his subjects in order to establish a point of contact - I was fortunate that I knew my subjects as I realise from this experience that getting the correct portrait is challenging if the subject is not wholly comfortable.  

    However, unlike Karsh with his famous tale of removing the cigar from Churchill, I chose to to photograph my crofter with his pipe as I felt this reflected his personality and allowed him to adopt a very relaxed pose!

















    Karsh stated that his portrait of Churchill changed his life and it is very reassuring for aspiring photographers to find out that Karsh had indeed been taking photographs for about 15 years before he got this break in his photography career.    

    Most of all, I am now aware that Yousuf Karsh himself held the strength of character, belief and determination, which he so admired in the great people he photographed in his time.  (Ref: see final quote below)

    Among his many awards, which included the Order of Canada in 1990, the International Edition of Who's Who In The World listed Karsh among the 100 most influential persons of the 20th century. Interestingly Karsh had photographed more than half of the people in the group and they would have been among the 15,000 sittings which he photographed over the years.  A truly inspirational photographer - he was indeed great.



    "I have found that great people do have in common .... an immense belief in themselves and in their mission.  They also have great determination as well as an ability to work hard.  At the crucial moment of decision, they draw on their accumulated wisdom. Above all, they have integrity."    Yousuf Karsh